In-House Kubernetes - Timeline Sanity Check

Date : December 28, 2024
Categories :
Tags : Kubernetes ,Like ,Building ,Solution ,Development

In-House Kubernetes - Timeline Sanity Check?

Introduction

Navigating the complexities of software architecture can be a daunting task, especially when faced with ambitious requests like building an in-house Kubernetes orchestrator. As a developer with 7.5 years of experience—4 in backend development and 3.5 in DevSecOps—the challenge is both exciting and intimidating. With the added pressure of working solo on this project, it’s crucial to assess the feasibility of the timeline and scope.

The Context

Currently, I’m part of a small Ops team servicing a larger group of 50 developers. My manager approached me with a request to build a Kubernetes-like system from scratch due to the lack of access to commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) orchestrators like OpenShift or Kubernetes. This challenge has sparked a mixture of enthusiasm and concern as I dive deep into architecture over the past three months, establishing job orchestration pipelines, artifact tracking, and metrics collection.

The Proposal

I initially estimated that I could complete this project in 8 months. However, after discussing the feasibility with colleagues and considering various perspectives, several points have emerged that warrant a deeper analysis:

1. Understanding the Requirements

Many comments highlighted the need to clarify the actual requirements. Were they asking for a full Kubernetes replacement or just a simpler container orchestration solution? It’s crucial to avoid the trap of “Not Invented Here Syndrome” and to focus on the minimum viable product (MVP) that meets the team’s needs without over-engineering.

2. Maintenance and Longevity

Building a system like Kubernetes is not just about the initial development. As several commenters pointed out, maintenance is a significant concern. The complexity of distributed systems can lead to a maintenance nightmare, especially for a solo developer. It’s essential to establish a clear plan for updates, bug fixes, and potential scaling issues before diving into development.

3. Feasibility of the Timeline

While 8 months might seem reasonable on the surface, it’s essential to consider the breadth of what needs to be achieved. Projects like Kubernetes were developed by large teams with extensive resources over several years. Attempting to replicate that effort as a single developer is ambitious, if not unrealistic. Comments from seasoned professionals suggest that it could take closer to a year or more to build a robust solution, especially one that needs to handle edge cases and scale appropriately.

4. Exploring Alternatives

Given the challenges of building a container orchestration system from scratch, it may be prudent to explore existing solutions. Several commenters emphasized the importance of leveraging existing tools like Kubernetes, even if it means navigating internal approval processes. Forking an existing solution or using tools like Terraform for infrastructure setup might provide a more efficient path forward.

5. Incremental Development

Several insights pointed towards the value of an incremental approach. Instead of aiming for a full-fledged orchestrator immediately, I could start with simpler functionalities and build upon that foundation. This could involve rolling out features in stages and ensuring that each component is thoroughly tested before moving on to the next.

6. Communication with Management

It’s vital to maintain open lines of communication with management regarding the scope of the project and the potential pitfalls. Some commenters suggested having a frank discussion about the implications of building such a system and the risks involved. This could help align expectations and perhaps lead to a reconsideration of the approach.

Conclusion

The journey of building an in-house Kubernetes system poses significant challenges. While the prospect of creating a tailored solution is enticing, the potential pitfalls cannot be ignored. By reassessing the scope, exploring existing tools, and communicating effectively with management, I can navigate this complex undertaking more strategically. Ultimately, the goal should be to deliver a maintainable, scalable solution that meets the needs of the team without overwhelming myself in the process.

As I prepare to embark on this project early next year, I appreciate the insights from fellow developers and look forward to further discussions on best practices and lessons learned in the world of container orchestration.

Unlock your potential! Schedule a 1-on-1 coaching session to streamline your Kubernetes journey today!

Schedule Now