When Your Entire Team is Great, Deciding on Merit Increases is Really Tough

As managers, we often face the daunting task of distributing merit increases, bonuses, and stock grants among our teams. Typically, we’re assigned a specific budget normalized to current salaries, regardless of our team dynamics. This can lead to tricky situations, especially when you find yourself managing a team where every member is performing at a high level.

In previous years, it was relatively straightforward to identify top performers. However, following a recent reorganization, I now find myself in the enviable yet perplexing position of having a team filled with exceptional talent. The challenge? How do we decide who gets what when everyone is deserving?

Understanding the Challenge

A common scenario is that a manager with ten low performers is given the same budget as one with ten high performers. From a managerial perspective, this feels inherently unfair. It raises the question: how do you differentiate between high performers when they all contribute significantly to the team’s success?

The Importance of Motivation

One positive aspect of this situation is that it reflects a motivated and engaged team. A team that consistently delivers strong results is a testament to effective leadership and a healthy work environment. However, it also requires us to approach merit increases with a nuanced strategy.

Strategies for Decision-Making

Here are some methodologies that can aid in making these tough decisions while ensuring fairness and transparency:

1. Identify Critical Contributions

Create a ranking of team members based on their contributions to key business outcomes (KLO). By identifying who is critical to the success of the business, you can allocate budget resources more effectively. For instance, if one engineer played a pivotal role in a successful project while others contributed equally but in less critical ways, it may make sense to adjust their merit increases accordingly.

2. Communicate the Reality

It’s vital to set realistic expectations with your team regarding raises and promotions. Emphasize that while it is impossible to promote everyone, career development is a marathon, not a sprint. This perspective can help mitigate feelings of disappointment and foster a culture of understanding and resilience.

3. Utilize Multiple Compensation Components

Annual bonuses often include several components: individual cash bonuses, annual RSU refreshers, and percentage base pay raises. Different levels within your team may place varying importance on these components. For example, junior engineers may prioritize immediate cash, while senior engineers might value stock options more highly. Tailoring your compensation strategy to align with individual preferences can help ensure that all team members feel valued.

4. Avoid the “Peanut Butter Spread”

One critical piece of advice I’ve received over the years is to avoid applying a “peanut butter spread” approach to merit increases. Even in a high-caliber team, it’s essential to differentiate based on relative performance. This not only rewards top performers but also motivates others to strive for improvement.

Conclusion

Navigating merit increases in a team of high performers can be one of the most challenging aspects of management. However, by employing strategic methodologies, being transparent about decision-making processes, and recognizing individual contributions, we can ensure that our team members feel valued and motivated to continue excelling.

As leaders, our role is not just to manage but to inspire growth and understanding within our teams. How do you handle merit increases in your team? Share your experiences and strategies in the comments below!

Related Posts

• What is your process of year-end merit increases / promotions
• What is your process of year-end merit increases / promotions?
• Top Performers or Underachievers - Who Defines Your Culture?
• Top Performers or Underachievers - Who Defines Your Culture
• Why TF did my company switch to TypeScript for backend work from C#